Artificial Intimacy, part 1 of 5

There is one thing about pornography that almost nobody names out loud, and it is not the obvious thing.

The obvious thing is what it shows you. Everybody knows that part. The part that gets missed is what it asks of you.

Nothing. It asks nothing.

When you open a video, you are not required to be kind. You are not required to be patient, or interesting, or faithful, or awake at 6am when someone needs you. Nobody on the other side of that screen is having a hard week. Nobody needs you to listen. There is no timing to read, no mood to notice, no history to carry, no forgiveness to ask for. The video does not need anything from you. It only gives you sensation.

And there is no way to give anything back. That is the part I keep chewing on. It is not that men fail to reciprocate. It is that reciprocation is structurally impossible. There is nobody there to receive it.

Sit with that for a second, because I think it explains more about the shape of a man's life than most of the sermons on the subject do.

What real closeness costs

Being close to a person costs you something every single time.

Your wife needs you to put the phone down. Your friend needs you to remember what he told you last month. Your kid needs you at exactly the moment you have nothing left. Real closeness has a bill attached: attention, patience, the willingness to be known by someone who can then use what they know.

That bill is not a flaw in the system. It is the system. The cost is what makes it intimacy instead of entertainment. You gave something up, and so did she, and the exchange is what binds you.

Porn removed the bill. Not all at once. In stages, and each stage removed a little more.

The stages

Watching, live. The oldest version required proximity. You had to be somewhere. There was risk, timing, and the very real possibility of being caught, so it stayed occasional for most people by force rather than by choice.

Printed images. Photographs and magazines detached the image from the moment. Now it could be owned, kept, returned to at will, and looked at on a Tuesday afternoon with no event required. Repeatable on demand.

Video. Motion, duration, and eventually the living room. Before the internet, most of it still moved through print and tape, which meant a store, a counter, a clerk, and the stigma of walking in. Getting it required a decision a man had to make in public.

The internet. In 1998, psychologist Al Cooper described what he called the Triple-A Engine: access, affordability, anonymity. His argument was that those three together would accelerate online sexual behavior past anything before it, and the phrase has been cited thousands of times since. Worth saying plainly that researchers have tested his model and gotten mixed results, so take it as a useful description rather than settled science. But the three conditions themselves are simply true. It became free, instant, and private.

The phone. This is the jump nobody planned for. The thing is now in your pocket. It is with you at work, in the car, in the bathroom, in bed next to your sleeping wife. There is no store, no clerk, no drive, no waiting, and almost no risk of discovery. Every friction that used to slow a man down has been engineered out.

Look at that sequence and you see one continuous project: the steady removal of everything that ever asked something of the user.

The cost went to zero. And when the cost goes to zero, so does the exchange.

The loop that will not close

Here is what I believe, and I will say up front that this is my conviction and not a study result.

Something in the body knows the loop did not close.

You feel arousal, escalation, release, and then a strange flatness that has no name. Not just guilt, though there is usually plenty of that. Something more like standing in an empty room after a conversation you thought you were having. The circuit went out and nothing came back. There was never anyone there to send anything back.

Do that a few thousand times and you have not just sinned a few thousand times. You have practiced something. You have rehearsed a version of closeness in which nothing is required of you, and the body learns what it rehearses.

Then a man carries that shape into a marriage, where everything is required of him, and wonders why being loved by an actual woman feels like so much work.

Why this matters more than the behavior

Most purity teaching aims at the behavior. Stop the thing. Install the filter. Count the days.

Those things matter. I am not against any of them. I have written a whole piece on why blocking software earns its place, because putting friction back into a system that had it engineered out is a real move.

But if the only thing you address is the behavior, you leave the training in place. A man can go ninety days clean and still be a man who has never had to be patient with anyone, never had to be known, never had to give anything to receive anything.

The behavior was the symptom. The training is the injury. What got trained into us is a way of receiving that demands nothing, and that training does not stop at the browser. It shows up in how we listen to our wives, how we take from our churches, how we do friendship at arm's length and call it fine. This is what I meant when I said it was not just a habit.

Freedom is not the absence of the video. It is the recovery of the ability to be in a relationship that costs you something and to want it anyway. Which is close to the reason I keep saying don't make purity the goal. Purity grows on a man who is actually connected, to God and to people. Aim at it directly and you get a man white knuckling an empty room.

The part that makes this urgent

For all of that history, the screen has been silent. It gives, you take, the loop stays open, and some part of you knows it.

That just changed. There is now something on the other side of the glass that answers.

But before we get there, we have to talk about why so many men are sitting in front of that screen with nobody else to talk to. Because this is not happening to men in a vacuum, and the numbers on that are worse than most of us realize.

Next in this series: You Don't Have a Porn Problem, You Have a Nobody Problem.

Sources